Baseball seems to have the most interesting politics when it comes to the Hall of Fame voting. All kinds of strange things go on for a variety of amusing reasons. To me there were three stories this year:
- How high a percentage would Ripkin and Gwynn get?
- How low a percentage would McGuire get?
- Would Goose Gossage finally make it?
Each of the questions has some hilarious political overtones. I say hilarious, because they have little to do with the question of who actually belongs in the Hall, but more to do with the process itself.
First, let’s discuss #3. For those unfamiliar with the issue here, only recently have relievers begun to be voted into the Hall of Fame. For a while that was an underappreciated specialty. Goose Gossage was one of the most fears relievers of his day and his numbers totally should place him in the hall. To get inducted you need 75% of the voters to vote for you (each voter can vote for up to 10 players). Gossage’s percentage has been rising steady each year of voting so some thought he had a shot this year. But he fell short at 71.2%.
Why did he fall short? Many voters, when there are a couple of obvious first ballot Hall of Famers (this is Ripkin and Gwynn’s first year of eligibility and they were obvious locks to get in), do not like to vote in other candidates the same year. They feel that having Gossage on the podium the same year as Gwynn and Ripkin would “clutter” the stage and detract from Ripkin and Gwynn. Next year there are no obvious first time candidates, so everyone assumes that Gossage will make it next year. But is he any less worthy this year? No, it’s just politics.
Item #1 is also political. Some voters do not believe that anyone should get 100% of the votes, under the “Babe Ruth didn’t get 100%” logic. Some voters submitted completely blank votes to protest the “steroid era”. One voter just picked 10 other players besides Gwynn and Ripkin because he figured those guys would get enough other votes.
And item #2 is the one we’ll all be debating (well, all baseball fans). McGuire didn’t break any rules of baseball. He’s the 7th all time home run hitter. But virtually everyone believes he took steroids and his performance in front of Congress was horrible.
That’s the fun of baseball. Endless debates…